jump to navigation

Free Speech in Pakistan? You’re serious? 20 November 2006

Posted by TwentyTwoYards in Hypocrisy, Land of the pure...and the not so pure.

Comment gone lengthy… (©: Knicq Enterprises) – in response to Sabizak’s comment on the previous post.

I do agree that many Westerners are of course admirably honest and diligent in their views of Jews and Israel – I have discussed a few of them (eg Finkelstein, Chomsky et al) here previously. However, even these guys are hardly mainstream. The dissenting voices of a few ‘leftwing’ intellectuals (the Ivy League tenured class) may be grudgingly tolerated but are never welcomed. The difficulties encountered by Professor Finkelstein when publishing his books in the US are just one stark reminder of the numerous controls on ‘free speech’. In any case, a few bastions of left-wing or anti-establishment rhetoric do not a country make.

When it comes to the mainstream discourse, even those mild criticisms of Israel are rebuked. The opprobrium and scorn heaped on Mearsheimer and Walt by their peers, by the media and by the wider America society, for stating what most of us outside the US would accept as being a ’statement of the bleedin’ obvious’ is eye-opening. The message is this: whilst its okay for lefties (eg Chomsky) or fascists (eg David Duke) to criticise Zionism, it certainly is not kosher for ‘normal’ folks to do so.

Secondly, I would submit that the reference to Pakistan is somewhat irrelevant here. We (Pakistanis, or Muslims, for that matter) do not claim to be paragons of “free speech” – in fact, our penal code and our society places visible and well-known controls on expression. To berate us for something we never claim to be in the first place seems a trifle harsh – whilst we never claim to be adherents of such dubious notions as ‘free speech’, “they” (ie the Western world as a collective) do! Hence, it is only proper that ‘they’ are held accountable by the standards they themselves proudly cherish and uphold, allegedly.

However, as Pakistan has been mentioned, it would be instructive to explore the issue. Sabizak wrote that in Pakistan, if you “publicly deny the ideology of pakistan”, your fate would not be the envy of many. Is this really borne out by the facts?

Pakistani print and electronic media is replete not only with denials and criticisms of the canard that is the public face of the ideology of Pakistan, but also contain veiled and not so veiled criticisms of many aspects of Islam. Even the recent fiasco that is the so-called “Women’s Protection Bill” was used by many in the ‘liberal intelligentsia’ as a convenient stick to hit Islam and Islamic concepts with, generally in a manner that had little relation to fact or reality. Every evening, loony lefties such as Pervez Hoodbhoy, Mehdi Hasan Rizvi, Samar Mubarak Ali et al fill Pakistani TV screens with semi-demented notions of what Pakistan should be or should not be – and these notions generally do involve robust critiques of Islam and of Pakistan as an Islamic state. Heavens have not fallen and these mouthpieces continue to receive their paychecks from their foreign or local paymasters – doesn’t sound like a particularly repressive environment to me.

I do agree that such criticism and free speech is rare and confined to the Western elite of the country, but that is often the case, even in richer countries. In Pakistan, even mainstream politicos like Iqbal Hiader, Umar Asghar etc openly and blatantly express sentiments that are not only inimical to Islam but often downright blasphemous – that does not seem to impact the vote bank of the political parties these gents caucus with.

Let me clarify – I am not implying that the above is necessarily a good thing or even something to be applauded – my personal view is that it is not – however, the fact that it exists should nonetheless be acknowledged.

Pakistan’s largest selling English language newspaper, The Dawn, is a bastion of ‘left-wing and anti-establishment rhetoric’, and has been for as long as I can remember. The newest decent entrant in the print media market, aka The Daily Times, has made a name for itself with its stridently ‘liberal’ (though not libertarian) and pro-West stances. Najam Sethi, Cowasjee, Dr Lodhi, Irfan Hussain, Khalid Ahmed, Ejaz Haider etc have all made a nice living out of this racket, and there are many more waiting to jump on the gravy train – if criticising Islam and Pakistan wasn’t so lucrative an enterprise, these guys would have been out of business. :-)

So no, being critical of Islam or Pakistan’s ideology in Pakistan is not a one-way ticket to gaol – it is a decision that makes sound commercial sense and is thus the choice made by many of the leading media barons of the country.



1. hemlock - 21 November 2006

Najam Sethi has been in jail for writing against establishment. Ejaz Haider, Khalid Ahmed and Irfan Hussain have been living off a racket called The Friday Times for over a decade now, so DT, if anything, was a step down from the throne.
DT has by far been the most outspoken paper in musharraf’s reign, at the same time, has been upfront in giving praise where and when it was due.
yes, If being critical of muslims, or a new-and-improved-to-suit-your-daily-needs version of islam, or a group of baton wielding men representing a nation of 160 million people is buying them advertisements, then yes, daily times is guilty on those accounts. at no time has DT ever put down the ideology, the country, or the religion it was based on in its four years of publication.
it is a paper written by the elite FOR the elite, and it speaks the one language they can understand; in an effort to perhaps bring about a change the country so desperately needs.

2. Abu Abdur Rahman - 28 November 2006

Hemlock – thank you for stopping by :-)

My reply to your comments merits a post of its own; at least I hope it does. One day, some day, I will write it and eagerly await the brickbats that will surely follow.

3. hemlock - 2 December 2006

one day, some day, i hope you will write that response. i will eagerly await it.
dunno about the brickbats though…

4. Moderate Enlightenment - 3 December 2006

hemlock: i will eagerly await it.

Khushi se mar ne jatey agar ‘aitebaar hota . . !

Waisey you have some cheek saying that, after bad-mouthing this poor wee blog for hours n hours the other day….! ;-)

5. hemlock - 8 December 2006

yeh na thee hamari kismet…

i returned to find two updates, and none about najam sethi…
you better believe im eagerly awaiting it… (and die of ecstacy therein)…

and no, i didnt badmouth your blog. i just said it was boring.

6. 258508 - 12 April 2011

What a lovely day for a 258508! SCK was here

7. Noticias En Tijuana - 27 April 2011

Hello there, Very good stuff here. I just wanted to add to the great content that I consider this is very good content and also worthwhile tips… thanks a lot for sharing this! Well done :)

8. Learn Spanish - 11 May 2011

Finally discovered very good and clear facts thanks to your webpage. Thanks for revealing this great work. Top marks for this! :) Thanks a lot

9. Cargadores laptop Mexicali - 13 July 2011

I only want to state that i found this website very usefull, the idea helped people understand the topic at hand drastically. I’d like to know how easily you generate articles for a site.

10. calories in quaker oatmeal squares - 21 August 2011

Hi all, Making it very appreciate all of the autor for the online site. Just about all is evident as well as sensible. The planning are often great in my opinion. Do you really please don’t hesitate to tel people discover the layout exactly what take advantage of? regards once more and thus continue on beneficial financial be effective.

11. Ulysse Nardin presents the "Caprice Panda" – (0 Replies) | I love Watches! - 25 October 2011

[…] heuer glasses tag heuer gozluk tag heuer grand carrera tag heuer grand carrera calibre 36 tag heuer handy tag heuer kirium tag heuer link tag heuer malaysia tag heuer […]

12. yoga insulin sensitivity weight loss for women only - 16 August 2014

yoga insulin sensitivity weight loss for women only

Free Speech in Pakistan? You’re serious? | Moderate Enlightenment

13. deals for shed building edmonton - 17 August 2014

deals for shed building edmonton

Free Speech in Pakistan? You’re serious? | Moderate Enlightenment

14. My little caravan craft workshops for kids and teens Melbourne - 18 March 2015

My little caravan craft workshops for kids and teens Melbourne

Free Speech in Pakistan? You’re serious? | Moderate Enlightenment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: